RSS Feed

Category Archives: Behind the Curtain

Anonymity and Free Speech on the Web

Posted on

I think we can all agree, the World Wide Web is a wonderful thing. After all, if it didn’t exist, you wouldn’t be reading my ramblings right now. And I do appreciate all my readers.

More importantly, the sharing of ideas and information around the world helps promote both knowledge and democracy. It demolishes stereotypes, diminishes ignorance and reduces fear.

But I fear the rise of instantaneous, worldwide communication, coupled with the anonymity of the Web, is also contributing to the decline of civil discourse.

It’s easy to hide behind our online identities. That makes it easy to say things we might not say if we were identified by name.  Normally, that’s a good thing (the Walrus said). It contributes to a free-spirited discussion. In nations with repressive governments, anonymity can be a matter of life or death for activists trying to change things.

But that very level of anonymous commenting also breeds a certain level of nastiness, one that I fear is becoming more prevalent.

Check out the comments on just about any news source website. It’s becoming exceptionally rare to find a story, any story, on any subject, that someone hasn’t seen fit to make partisan political comments about. And not just typical politics, but really angry screeds that disintegrate into name-calling and insults.

More and more commenters are getting personal with their slurs. They often reject the idea that people who disagree with them are even human, let alone entitled to a different opinion.

And that leads to a reaction, but probably not the one that the posters intend. Instead of agreement, such arguments tend to turn people off, leading to a cynical sense of “a pox on both your houses.”

There are darker corners as well. While searching for something entirely unrelated the other day, I stumbled across a vicious, angry, misogynist site whose posters clearly view women as something less than human. I felt like I needed a shower after reading such trash. Other sites promote racism, anti-Semitism, and discrimination against those defined as “others.” It’s enough to discourage even the most ardent free speech absolutist.

But here’s the thing — I pretty much AM that First Amendment absolutist. As much as I’d like to see the slime disappear, I am compelled to fight to protect it. I firmly believe the antidote to hate speech is more speech, not less. If we try to suppress hate speech, we give it power and mystery. Better to hash it out in the open, no matter how repugnant we may find it. Free speech is not always pretty, but it is necessary.

Whoever said the pen is mightier than the sword knew what they were talking about. Words are powerful. Choose them wisely.

Advertisements

Proofreading: A Lost Art

Posted on

jimromenesko.com

This one kinda speaks for itself.

Top 10 List of Great Lists!

Posted on

OK, I lied in the title. You’ll find no list here. There simply doesn’t need to be one.

If you’re really looking for lists, there are gazillions of them out there on the Web already. You name it, there’s a list for it somewhere:

700 Habits of Highly Obsessive-Compulsive People

12 Ways to Beat Attention Deficit — Wait, What’s That?

These 4 Things Happen Right Before the Zombie Apocalypse

And on and on, ad infinitum, ad nauseam. You can’t swing a lolcat on the internet without hitting a list of some kind. But why?

Because just about everybody likes lists. They’re fun to read. Everybody has a Top 10 something or other. Even the Walrus is not immune. I read lists with the best of ’em — Top 10 Cars of the Millennium, 10 Worst Songs of the Decade, 5 Tips for Better Drinks at the Latte Emporium, etc.

But here’s the dirty little secret to lists — from a writer’s standpoint, they’re a lazy way out. Can’t think of anything to say? Compile a list! They’re fast, easy, and make it look like you have something to say, when far too often, you have nothing to contribute to the conversation.

Don’t get me wrong, lists do have their place. I’m all for learning better ways to do things, whether it’s saving money, removing wallpaper or making a better grilled cheese sandwich. You can even expect to find a list of some kind or another here in the Cafe occasionally.

But a successful list requires more than just a simple regurgitation of collected wisdom. If you’re going to do a list, contribute something original to it. Don’t just parrot the same old tired bromides over and over again.

On that note, gotta run. I’m busy compiling a list of the top 10 reasons to dislike lists.

%d bloggers like this: